RIN Blog
Blog Home All Blogs

PNT Advisory Group Update May 2024

Posted By Andy Proctor, 31 May 2024
The Regular PNT Advisory Board meeting has been moved to around the time of the RIN AGM to be able to finally have a face-to-face discussion, this update is to keep group members appraised on what has been going on behind the scenes at RIN HQ! You will of course have seen the updates in Navigation News about the activities we are pursuing and of course many members have attended the events, but there is more to come: 


PNT and Quantum 

Look into the future of navigation and timing with our Quantum Positioning and Navigation Technology (PNT) event coming later this year. Quantum PNT harnesses the principles of quantum mechanics such as superposition and entanglement, to attempt to offer unparalleled accuracy and resilience in positioning and timing.
Quantum sensors can detect minute changes in the environment with unprecedented sensitivity. These sensors measure gravitational fields, accelerations, and rotations. Will these sensors enable breakthroughs in inertial navigation, providing autonomous systems with precise positioning and orientation capabilities in challenging or GNSS-denied environments? The potential performance improvements are game-changing, but so are the challenges to realise them. 
Quantum clocks claim to pave the way for ultra-precise timekeeping essential for modern applications. Quantum clocks harness the inherent properties of quantum particles by trapping and interrogating individual atoms or ions, to create an ultra-stable reference signal. 
So-called quantum algorithms are looking to exploit future quantum computing's potential to revolutionise navigation and timing tasks, solving complex problems at an exponentially higher speed than currently.

The RIN PNT Advisory Group plans to offer the potential to gain insights into the latest advancements, exchange ideas, and collaborate on shaping the future of Quantum PNT. Whether you're an enthusiast, researcher, or industry leader, our event will offer the chance to expand your network and foster collaborations that drive innovation forward.

More to come when available.

 

The Intersection of AI and PNT

Our new focus area investigates the intersection between Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Positioning, Navigation, and Timing (PNT) to understand how AI might shape the future of performance and efficiency. As we navigate an increasingly complex and interconnected world, AI could be a powerful ally in enhancing the capabilities of PNT systems. Using advanced algorithms and machine learning techniques, AI augments traditional positioning and navigation methods, enabling smarter, more adaptive systems capable of real-time decision-making and autonomous operation. AI-driven data fusion techniques claim to integrate diverse sensor data sources dynamically to enhance positioning accuracy and performance, even in challenging environments such as urban canyons or dense foliage. 

The integration of AI and PNT unlocks a multitude of possibilities across various industries and sectors, including timing, autonomous vehicles, precision agriculture, emergency response and urban mobility. There is a lot of hype around what AI can do, the RIN as always will take a balanced, evidence-led approach to try and avoid this hype. 

Together with Cambridge Wireless we will be hosting an event tackling the subject of "Navigating the AI Revolution in PNT" on 10 July. In this half-day event run by Cambridge Wireless and the Royal Institute of Navigation we will be hearing from experts across academia and industry and discussing where we think AI can have the most significant impact on Positioning Navigation and Timing.  RIN Members can join this event free of charge - keep an eye out on your e-mails for a discount code!

Join our community of innovators helping to understand and drive this evolution of AI and PNT by signing up to the special interest group of the mailing list. Watch out for further event announcements soon and let us know if you have ideas to investigate!

 

International Collaboration

In an increasingly interconnected world, collaboration is key. PNT Advisory Group Exec team member Professor Terry Moore is also a member of the US PNT Advisory Board, a Federal group formally advising the US Government. RIN Fellow Renato Filjar also attends this board. Through strategic partnerships with this Board and international colleagues, we can harness the collective expertise and resources of the RIN and other organisations to face head-on the common challenges and opportunities for innovation in PNT technology and policy. 

The presence of RIN members at this prestigious US event, held twice a year, means that activities in the UK and the events and discussion we have, get fed directly into the advice presented to both the US and UK Governments, plus those international partners who attend. It also facilitates collaboration with international standards organisations and regulatory bodies to ensure the reliability and accuracy of PNT services globally.

PNT is essential to space sustainability and debris removal


Space debris, ranging from defunct satellites to spent rocket stages, poses a significant risk to active spacecraft and critical infrastructure in orbit. With millions of objects orbiting the Earth at varying velocities, even small fragments have the potential to cause catastrophic collisions, generating more debris in a cascading effect known as the Kessler syndrome.

PNT technologies play a vital role in tracking and monitoring space debris, providing precise positioning data and accurate timing information essential for predicting potential collision events and avoiding hazardous encounters. These are delivered through ground-based and space-based sensors, radar systems, and optical telescopes. From collision avoidance manoeuvres to end-of-life disposal protocols, effective mitigation strategies against the impact of debris issues, rely on timely and accurate PNT solutions to ensure the safe and sustainable operation of spacecraft in orbit. 

The PNT advisory group have held initial discussions on the need for an event or activity to explore the challenge of space debris further. No conclusions have been reached but this early discussion has already thrown up interesting topics that could be potentially critical for the future. Professor Marek Ziebart will be giving a talk on this topic at the RIN AGM and Annual review meeting, sign up now.

 

Inertial systems and Autonomy

The wider RIN team, together with InnovateUK, The Centre for Connected and Autonomous Vehicles (CCAV) and Zenzic have delivered part one of a 2-part event that investigated the need and use of inertial navigation systems in platforms such as autonomous vehicles, drones, and robotics delivering new capability to navigate with accuracy and autonomy.

Inertial navigation systems (INS) serve as the backbone of autonomy, providing continuous position, velocity, and attitude information based on the integration of accelerometers and gyroscopes. The event series discusses the evolution of INS technology, from traditional strapdown systems to advanced MEMS-based sensors, and their applications across land, sea, air, and space domains.

By combining INS with complementary positioning technologies such as GNSS, LiDAR, and computer vision, autonomous systems can achieve centimetre-level accuracy even in GNSS denied environments. Our event showed that inertial navigation offers resilience against GNSS outage, signal interference, and adverse weather conditions, and that the innovation landscape in this area is alive and well. 

The next event in the series in in November 2024 and will focus on integration of inertial technology in to vehicle systems and supply chains. 

 

PNT Best Practices

The PNT Advisory Group and the Technical Committee chair are working with the UK National PNT Office on developing a set of PNT resilience principles and best practice guidance for our Critical National Infrastructure (CNI). 

PNT services underpin the operation of CNI, providing accurate timing, precise positioning, and reliable synchronisation essential for the functioning of sectors such as telecommunications, energy, transportation, and finance. 

Awareness of the use, vulnerabilities, and risks associated with PNT within the CNI has now been acknowledged as needing to improve, in the UK National Risk Register and the UK PNT Framework . The RIN and its membership are engaged to develop a set of principles and practices to not only continue to raise awareness of how to mitigate against the impact of loss of the primary PNT source (normally GPS), but the delivery of these to the Government will go a long way to improve, if implemented, the resilience of our CNI, public safety, and economic stability in an ever-changing threat landscape. 

Expanding the Frontiers of PNT in Low Earth Orbit (LEO)


LEO satellites offer unique advantages for PNT applications, including lower latency, enhanced coverage, and greater accessibility to remote regions. LEO PNT offers fertile ground for innovation and entrepreneurship in the PNT sector. Startups and emerging ventures are levering LEO-based PNT technologies to develop groundbreaking applications in precision agriculture, autonomous transportation, smart cities, disaster response, and beyond. 

Unlocking the full potential of PNT delivered by capabilities in LEO requires collaborative efforts between government agencies, industry stakeholders, academia, and international partners. 

Following a very successful LEO PNT event some time ago, discussions are under way to hold a second LEO PNT event and monitor the progress since the last event. 

 

The European Navigation Conference 2024

This update is finished just as ENC2024 is coming to a successful close. Reports and updates from the conference will come out in Navigation News in due course, but for me the take aways are: 

Well over 300 people attended which resulted in lots of new connections made.
There is more early-stage research than expected in PNT being carried out across Europe.
The UK is firmly on the right track regarding its thoughts on PNT, and the creation of the National PNT Office is being seen as leading the way from a national standpoint. 
Our previous work on LEO PNT has shown that the RIN is keeping track with the market as LEO PNT was a significant topic, as were the impacts on interference and spoofing – space vehicles impacted was mentioned in Prof Todd Humphrey’s keynote.
The ESA FutureNav and Moonlight programme are really pushing the bounds of technology with UK companies well involved, even if the headlines don’t seem so.
Well done to Terry, Ramsey, John, Clare, Louisa, Hannah and the ESA team for a fantastic event!

Conclusion

The PNT Advisory Group Exec team have been busy and continue to be so, the PNT best practice development will shortly be opened to the community of those who have expressed an interest in participating. The attendance at meetings and events has been encouraging and there are more in the planning stage as this blog notes. There is a close working relationship between the PNT AG and the RIN Technical Committee and the rest of the RIN HQ team. There are always many ideas on the list of things that we could do, and we must focus rather than being too broad, but if you would like to get involved more closely, contact the RIN Director or the Chair of the PNT AG, Andy Proctor.  
 

Tags:  PNTAG  Resilient PNT  RIN PNT Advisory Group 

PermalinkComments (0)
 

UK Government’s 10 Point Resilient PNT framework is welcome news for the RIN PNT Advisory Group

Posted By Andy Proctor and Guy Buesnel, 06 November 2023

UK Government’s 10 Point Resilient PNT framework is welcome news for the RIN PNT Advisory Group 

By Guy Buesnel and Andy Proctor 

 

UK Government announces a Resilient PNT Framework

The UK government has announced its long awaited Resilient PNT framework including a crisis plan, to support UK Critical National Infrastructure and essential services, which have all been identified as being critically dependent on the use of PNT data from GNSS. 
The plan includes the following points:
Establishing a National PNT Office in the Department of Science, Innovation and Technology (DSIT) with responsibility for PNT policy, coordination, and delivery    
Retain and update the Cross Government PNT Crisis Plan     
Develop a proposal for a National Timing Centre
Develop a proposal for ‘Ministry of Defence Time’ 
Develop a proposal for a resilient, terrestrial, and sovereign eLORAN system to provide backup Position and Navigation  
Rollout resilient GNSS receiver chips, develop holdover clocks, and consider options for legislation on CNI sectors to require minimum resilient PNT   
Develop a proposal for a UK PPP Satellite-Based Augmentation System 
Explore options for Centres for Doctoral Training PNT  and review PNT skills, education, and training 
Develop a PNT growth policy, including R&D programmes, standards and testing, to drive innovation for PNT based productivity   
Deploy existing R&D funding into a UK Quantum Navigator and investigate options for a UK sovereign regional satellite system   

 

10-Point plan broadly welcomed by PNT community

The UK government believes that “strengthening PNT capabilities will give direction to the PNT industry, whilst fostering innovation, growth, and cutting-edge technology development, positioning the UK as a global PNT leader.”

This is welcome news for the UK academia and industry experts who have been raising awareness of the overdependence on GNSS in critical infrastructure and other application areas.  
It also comes on the back of a updated London Economics study into the economic impact to the UK of a major disruption to GNSS, which noted that the impact of loss had risen from a conservative £1.1billion in 2017 to £1.4billion in 2021.

 

RIN PAG White paper addresses adoption of Resilient PNT

The announcement by the government was very timely, coming just a few weeks before the RIN holds its second “Leadership in PNT” event at the Royal Society and just after the publication of the updated UK National Risk Register, which included a risk of loss of PNT, and the publication of a RIN authored paper by the National Preparedness Commission noting the need to be more prepared for the loss of PNT services. In addition, the RIN PNT Advisory Group’s (PAG) published a white paper, “Recommendations to Promote the Adoption of Resilient Position, Navigation and Timing in the UK - With Growing Capabilities Come Growing Threats


The white paper, the first major publication from the RIN PNT Advisory group asserts that Resilient PNT is an area in which the UK could provide leadership to improve PNT performance given the high level of expert knowledge and track record in innovation and excellence that the UK possesses.


The RIN PAG has been involved in activities to support decision makers, regulators, industry, academia, and all involved in developing the Resilient PNT framework for the UK. It is developing plans to carry its work forward during 2024 and beyond; setting out tasks to support the government and National PNT office in the delivery of its ten-point framework will be high on its agenda.  As well as developing and publishing its recommendations on the adoption of Resilient PNT in the UK, the Advisory Group since its formation has looked at the role of Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellites for delivering PNT services,  is involved in work to assess the need for a dedicated UK PNT Innovation Institute and national test framework, and is assessing the impact of new PNT technologies such as Quantum and AI. The PAG also will continue working with the Ministry of Defence on the use of PNT in defence, and ways to improve, nurture and grow the UK skills base.  

“Multi-faceted Endeavour”

John Pottle, Director of the Royal Institute of Navigation, commented that the very welcome announcement by the government recognised that achieving greater PNT resilience was a multi-faceted endeavour. The ownership provided by the National PNT Office would provide policy and delivery oversight, and co-ordination across all stakeholders.    


As well as improving national preparedness, the PNT framework has potential to help further strengthen the UK’s thought leadership and innovation in robust and resilient PNT.   


Andy Proctor, Chair of the RIN PNT Advisory Group also welcomed the government’s announcement of the ten- point plan for a resilient PNT framework for the UK and said 
“The announcement of the measures and recommendations set out in the framework are a welcome step forward in addressing the vulnerabilities due to the UK’s dependency on satellite-based PNT, particularly GNSS. GNSS supports around £320 billion (15%)* of UK GDP, improving the UK’s PNT robustness, security and resilience will be key to mitigating vulnerabilities to the loss of satellite-based PNT, and to capture the significant growth opportunities that the framework could enable.”

 

Challenges ahead

Recent world events are reinforcing the need for improved PNT robustness, security, and resilience across critical applications and national infrastructure – but the road ahead to implement the framework will not be without bumps – the UK is rapidly approaching its next General Election and whilst the National PNT Office will be working very hard to develop more detailed costed plans for the framework, there are bound to be some uncertainties and delays in moving the plans forward. The RIN has a strong role to play in providing government with a source of knowledge, expertise, and support that it can rely on whilst it tackles more challenging task of making the framework a reality. 


As a learned society, the RIN brings a well-balanced voice to the task of raising awareness of PNT security and the need for responsible use of PNT more generally across society.


If you are interested in becoming a contributor to the RIN PAG work being planned for 2024, please contact either Andy Proctor (PAG Chair), Guy Buesnel (PAG Secretary) or Clare Stead (RIN Communications and Events Manager ) in the first instance.

* According to the 2022 UKSA Size and Health of the UK Space Industry Study

 

Tags:  pnt  resilient pnt  RIN PNT Advisory Group 

PermalinkComments (0)
 

RIN PNT Advisory Group – White Paper Release Ahead of Leadership in PNT Seminar

Posted By Andy Proctor and Guy Buesnel, 21 September 2023

RIN PNT Advisory Group – White Paper Release Ahead of Leadership in PNT Seminar

By Andy Proctor and Guy Buesnel

The RIN PNT Advisory group Executive group met recently and a significant topic of discussion was the initial release of the RIN white paper “Recommendations to promote the adoption of Resilient Position, Navigation and Timing in the UK”. This is an important milestone for the RIN PNT Advisory Group.  

The report makes some significant recommendations on the best ways forward to drive a greater understanding and adoption of the principles of Resilient PNT in the UK.

In his foreword to the report, Professor Terry Moore, former RIN president and Professor Emeritus at the University of Nottingham, details how society has become increasingly dependent on the services provided by PNT and that the increasing vulnerability of these services has become a critical issue to resolve.

The authors of the white paper, Ramsey Faragher and Mitch Narins (both FRIN’s), with support from the RIN PNT Advisory Group, believe that Resilient PNT is an area in which the UK could provide leadership to improve PNT performance given the high level of expert knowledge and track record in innovation and excellence that the UK possesses.  

A RIN- led approach is advocated by the authors who go on to make several key findings and recommendations as a result of their research – which they believe could be transformational to the future of Resilient PNT.

The paper was produced to help understand the values of developing standards, guidelines, and/or legislation for Resilient PNT in an already complex eco-system.  The importance of protecting Critical National Infrastructure from the consequences of increased vulnerability of PNT services to disruptions, was a strong driver in developing the findings and recommendations.

The paper considers the UK’s key strengths in PNT, making the point that the UK has historically been a global leader in PNT from the establishment of the longitude act (and prize) in 1714 following pressure from seafarers, the origins of the Greenwich meridian first established by Sir George Airy in 1851, and the “battle of the beams” in  World War II,  where the UK pioneered many radio navigation aids, counter-measures to defend against German radio based navigation technologies and early terrain-mapping radar navigation systems.  The UK carried this expertise forward into the 21st century and has taken leading roles in notable areas such as signals and control for GNSS systems, PNT satellites, receiver development smartphone navigation, precise timing transfer and control, system integration, PNT-enabled applications, and test measurement and verification.
The report goes on to examine the challenges facing PNT today and discusses existing PNT standards and guidance to propose a way forward to develop UK Resilient PNT best practice and guidelines. 

It is a wide-ranging white paper and contains a wealth of information along with its measured recommendations and conclusions.
With the “2nd Leadership in PNT” event being planned to take place at the Royal Society on 07 November 2023 the white paper will obviously be a major discussion point on the day.  A panel session at the event is being planned along with a video introduction from the two principal authors.   Event delegates will have the opportunity to read the white paper in advance of the seminar and to provide their input – and additionally they will be able to register their interest in being directly involved in the follow up activities proposed by the white paper. This will be an excellent opportunity for attendees to play a significant part in contributing to the development and excellence of a strong UK approach to Resilient PNT, and to the development of the RIN programme over the next year.

Andy Proctor, Chair of the UK PNT Advisory Group, and the part of organising committee for the Leadership in PNT event, hailed the release of the RIN white paper, “Standards, best practices, and legislation play an important role in the resilience and preparedness, to disruption, of infrastructure that uses PNT now and into the future. This new initiative and proposed working group could bring together UK expertise in the field to address the challenges it identifies.”

The RIN PNT Advisory group is also working on matters relating to Artificial Intelligence, Quantum Sensing, PNT in Defence, and PNT Innovation. It also taking learning from across the RIN from its other groups, such as the newly formed Maritime Navigation Group and the Cognitive Navigation groups, some of this learning will also be discussed at the Leadership event in November. Register here.

Tags:  PNTAG  resilient pnt  RIN PNT Advisory Group  white paper 

PermalinkComments (0)
 

New technologies present new challenges to PNT - the RIN PNT Advisory Group Executive Committee meeting had a lot to cover at its 23rd May meeting.

Posted By Andy Proctor and Guy Buesnel, 26 June 2023

New technologies present new challenges to PNT - the RIN PNT Advisory Group Executive Committee meeting had a lot to cover at its 23rd May meeting.  

UK PNT Advisory Group (PAG) Chair Andy Proctor and PAG Secretary Guy Buesnel report on the committees wide-ranging discussions.

The PNT Advisory Group Executive Committee met last month online; the topics discussed include:
Advances in Quantum technologies for PNT
The rise of Artificial Intelligence
PNT in Automation/autonomous systems 
The role of PNT Standards or Guidance in improving systems or equipment resilience 
Developing a communications strategy for the committee
Improving committee participation and International Reach 
Forthcoming RIN Defence Seminar at Aerospace Bristol
Following up the recent LEO event
A review of PNT Advisory Group Activities

Defence PNT

An area focussed on was the forthcoming RIN Defence Seminar at Aerospace Bristol on 03 July.  The MoD wants to reconnect with companies and individuals in the Defence Sector on PNT matters. RIN and the Advisory Group has developed a one-day programme of talks and discussion to enable discussions and networking. The event is especially important given the recent news stories detailing how an inertial navigation sensor has undergone trials on a Royal Navy warship.

The Seminar’s focus will be on 
What is meant by "resilient PNT" and "assured PNT"?
How should threats and hazards be considered?
Development of requirements for defence PNT systems
Approaches to assessing risks at different levels from modules to integrated systems
Mitigation approaches and their relative/absolute effectiveness
Research and development challenges
Latest developments in PNT for defence applications

The programme will have presentations from MoD and DSTL personnel in the morning and two panel discussions in the afternoon session. The event moderator is the RIN PNT Advisory Group Chair, Andy Proctor


The talks will include: -
Keynote: Wing Cdr Mark Brammer, MOD
Briefing from Strategic Command, Space Capability Planning (SATCOM & PNT) - Al Harris, PNT Desk Officer
Briefing from DSTL on their activities - Rob Handley, Acting Chief PNT Scientist
Briefing from DE&S - Jonathan Wilson
Briefing from DSC on their activity - Stuart Snedden, Space Team, UK Defence Solutions Centre

The afternoon panel discussions will concentrate on “Threats and Disruptions” and “Systems Thinking/Infrastructure protection”.

The last few places for this event are available here:  https://rin.org.uk/events/EventDetails.aspx?id=1748439

Low Earth Orbit (LEO) PNT

The Advisory Group discussed how best to follow up the recent RIN LEO PNT Seminar. RIN hosted the event in March 2023 to encourage a discussion and debate, under “Chatham House rules”, to discuss the technical, value chain, resilience, and business model challenges of providing PNT services from large satellite constellations. The event centred around open discussion, independence, and the objective of bringing the challenges forward for debate. 
These challenges include frequency selection, orbit determination and prediction accuracy (noted by a few attendees as “hard for LEO”); concept of operation (doppler or time-of-arrival), and the integration with other, linked services (independence and interoperability). 
Of greater concern in the room was the lack of clear business models from most of the LEO PNT providers. That is understandable as companies are reluctant to expose their models in front of their competitors. But there was less clarity in the room about why someone would pay for additional PNT services from space.

Approximately 100 people attended in person from over 40 organisations, UK and beyond, spanning users, service providers, equipment manufacturers and government officials.

The Advisory Group noted that a follow up by RIN is needed as the one-day seminar attracted some very lively debate and argument and succeeded in highlighting several key areas where significant challenges remain.

“Standards damn Standards”

The role of standards or guidance in increasing the resilience of systems or equipment is being discussed with the PAG preparing a white paper in this area. Its author Ramsey Farragher had opened the paper up to contributions from the rest of the executive committee. 

RIN PAG Chair Andy Proctor outlined the evolving US IEEE P1952 standard and its focus on resilience levels.  He speculated as to whether this approach would succeed in adding value to the PNT community but also stated that there was a need for intervention, be it a standard, guidance or even a code of conduct.  An analysis of the US Resilience Conformance Framework would be part of developing the correct intervention.

The meeting noted it is necessary to help users assess their current levels of resilience – there is nothing available to support presently.  This links to the other PAG activity on if there is a need for a UK PNT test bed, which is being consulted upon. The “standards” report is nearly completed and the executive committee discussed whether an RIN event on standards to coincide with the release of the document, would be worth considering. 

This blog invites recipients to feedback to the RIN on if a seminar on PNT standards/guidance/best practice would be welcomed. Please contact RIN Communications and Events Manager Clare Stead at comms@rin.org.uk with any feedback

Ensuring better communications

The group Secretary Guy Buesnel also presented plans to develop a coherent communications strategy for the RIN PAG which could be widely used to achieve consistency and greater reach for the group, including keeping members on the mailing list up to date.

The Committee also unanimously decided to issue approve the admission of Mitch Narins FRIN to the PNT Advisory Committee Exec team.  Mitch has been a prolific contributor to the work of the RIN and to developing Systems thinking for achieving PNT resilience and in developing usable standards to improve PNT Resilience. Mitch was employed with the FAA for more than 26 years, becoming Chief Systems Engineer for Navigation Services. He is also an Adjunct Professor at George Washington University, a member of the editorial advisory board for GPS World, magazine, a member of the Corporate Faculty at Harrisburg University of Science and Technology, is a Fellow of the RIN and is now the Principal Consultant and owner of Strategic Synergies, LLC.  Mitch will bring a wealth of industrial and academic expertise to the committee as well as a US perspective on Resilient PNT affairs.
The PNT Advisory Group always welcomes suggestions and inputs on PNT matters, large or small. Feel free to get in touch. 

Andy and Guy. 

 

Tags:  LEO  Low Earth Orbit Satellites  PNT  Positioning Navigation and Timing  resilient pnt  RIN PNT Advisory Group  RIN Special Interest Group 

PermalinkComments (0)